By Tina Cheung
With research by Ankita Diwan
Introduction
Windfall gifts are large, often unrestricted donations that represent a significant share of an organization’s annual operating budget, fundraising revenue, or available resources. While practitioner literature does not define a universal monetary threshold, these gifts are generally large enough to materially influence how organizations plan, budget, operate, deliver programs, and make strategic decisions. In this article, windfall gifts refer to unrestricted monetary contributions that are substantial enough to prompt organizations to pause and reassess how decisions are made, resources are allocated, and long-term planning and priorities are determined.
According to MacKenzie Scott’s Yield Giving platform, Scott has distributed more than 26 billion dollars in unrestricted gifts to more than 2,700 nonprofit organizations since 2020. Practitioner literature often describes these gifts as high-impact philanthropic transfers. Scott is one of the most prominent examples of this type of giving. However, philanthropic data such as the latest Forbes’ ranking of America’s top philanthropists, highlight that she is part of a broader ecosystem of major donors, including George Soros, Lynn and Stacy Schusterman, and John and Laura Arnold, whose lifetime contributions span billions of dollars, even though their giving structures and focus areas vary.
When organizations receive windfall gifts, they must decide how funds are allocated and governed, including the development of clear decision-making processes, oversight structures, and accountability mechanisms.
In this article, governance is grounded in a definition found in “Nonprofit Good Governance Mechanisms: A Systematic Literature Review” by Ana Licerán-Gutiérrez, Antonio Luis Moreno-Albarracín, Cristina Ortega-Rodríguez, and Lucía Martín-Montes in Nonprofit Management and Leadership, published in 2024. They describe governance as the way authority is exercised and how an organization is managed, operated, and controlled by its leadership and board. This includes the systems, policies, and processes that guide decision-making, accountability structures, transparency, and relationships with stakeholders. This framing allows us to understand how organizations make decisions when they receive a windfall gift.
Windfall gifts can alter organizations by providing new resources and opportunities; however, the actual impact of that change depends on an organization’s governance systems. As organizations determine how those resources are allocated, their existing governance systems are amplified and revealed. Organizations with strong governance can accelerate strategic priorities and impacts. In organizations with weaker or more informal governance processes, they often bring forth issues around a lack of prioritization, the uneven allocation of resources, tension between leadership and boards, and unclear decision-making frameworks.
This matters because windfall gifts can change how organizations make decisions around budgeting, prioritization, and long-term planning. Instead of working with predictable annual funding cycles, organizations suddenly have access to large and unexpected resources that require clearer governance structures and greater alignment between leadership and boards.
Across practitioner literature and reports from The Bridgespan Group, Panorama Global, and Successful Nonprofits, a common theme emerges: the greatest challenge is often not receiving the unexpected gift itself, but the decision-making that follows it.
Understanding Windfall Gifts in the Nonprofit Sector
In “Deciding How to Invest a Windfall Gift” by The Bridgespan Group, windfalls often require organizations to develop strategies that span multiple years, often beyond annual budgeting cycles. Similarly, “Making and Managing Windfall Gifts” by Panorama Global in 2022 highlights that organizations are often not aligned on how to best use a windfall. Some boards prefer to preserve funds for rainy days, while others advocate for rapid spending without sufficient alignment between leadership and governance bodies.
In “Receiving a Large, Unrestricted Grant: A 90-Day Roadmap” by Panorama Global, published in 2023, and “Is Your Nonprofit Ready for a Windfall?” by Successful Nonprofits, published in 2020, a key takeaway is that nonprofits should proactively create decision-making structures, windfall policies, and alignment between boards and leadership before receiving a major gift.
Similarly, governance literature, including BoardSource and Boards that Make a Difference: A New Design for Leadership in Nonprofit and Public Organizations by John Carver in 2006, points to a consistent theme: nonprofit organizations benefit when they have clarity with clearly defined roles and responsibilities for their leadership and boards, decision-making rights, and accountability structures. BoardSource emphasizes that effective governance takes place when there is clarity on who makes decisions, how oversight is exercised, and how organizations maintain mission alignment and remain accountable to their stakeholders.
Governance Challenges After a Windfall
When an organization receives a windfall, typically the challenge is not the funds itself. Rather, it is the decision-making environment it creates.
Organizations typically face:
- Lack of alignment between leadership and its board on pacing and priority areas.
- Unclear decision-making authority on fund allocation.
- Pressure to quickly spend the funds without a shared strategic framework.
- Challenges in balancing the allocation of funds to address immediate needs versus long-term investments.
According to “Making and Managing Windfall Gifts”, organizations that lack governance structures and spending plans may encounter donor assumptions that the organization no longer needs additional funding, uneven distribution of resources across programs, increased cybersecurity risks, hacking threats, public visibility risks, and internal tension between leadership and boards regarding how funds are spent.
These challenges are often more visible when governance systems are poorly defined or informal. Meanwhile, organizations with strong governance structures are better equipped to align on decision-making, manage trade-offs, and strategically allocate its new resources.
Governance Recommendations for Managing a Windfall Gift
The literature consistently recommends that organizations pause, assess, and develop a strategy before spending a windfall.
Organizations should view a windfall as an opportunity to make intentional investments that strengthen long-term impact and organizational capacity rather than treating it as unrestricted funds that they would spend immediately. In “Deciding How to Invest a Windfall Gift,” The Bridgespan Group encourages leaders to consider how a windfall can accelerate mission outcomes and organizational capacity, while “Three Tips for Unlocking Board Effectiveness After a Windfall Gift” by Carmita Semaan, published in 2024, emphasizes the value of engaging boards for their expertise and as strategic partners in planning, innovation, and financial stewardship.
Similarly, in “Receiving a Large, Unrestricted Grant: A 90-Day Roadmap,” practitioners reported that organizations benefited from taking time to reflect, assess internal capabilities, engage their governance boards, and develop communication and financial strategies before allocating funds.
Strong governance will allow your organization to: focus on long-term impact rather than short-term spending, align investments with mission and values, strengthen leadership and governance capacity, and preserve flexibility for future opportunities.
This article introduces a four-part governance framework for leaders managing windfall gifts based on practitioner literature and governance principles from Bridgespan, Panorama Global, Successful Nonprofits, and Carmita Semaan’s recommendations.The framework is designed to guide decision-making before allocating funds and focuses on four key areas: creating a windfall governance policy, assessing organizational capacity, determining priority investment areas, and engaging board and stakeholders.
A Governance Framework for Managing Windfall Gifts
This framework includes four components that organizations can use to guide decision-making, align resources with their mission and priority areas, and strengthen accountability when receiving a windfall gift.
#1 Create a Windfall Governance Policy
Creating a windfall governance policy helps organizations determine how decisions are made in order to manage windfall funds in a way that is consistent, transparent, and aligned with organizational priorities.
- Determine what constitutes a major gift for your organization to ensure that the appropriate governance processes are implemented when those thresholds are reached.
- Establish how spending decisions are made by specifying who has the authority to approve, allocate, and manage windfall-related spending.
- Create a document that outlines the decision-making process for reviewing proposals, approving allocations, and how fund usage is tracked across time.
- Create a communication strategy that outlines how decisions regarding a windfall are shared across stakeholders, including staff, members, donors, and external parties.
#2 Assess and Understand Organizational Capacity Before Allocating Funds
Before allocating funds, organizations should assess and understand their internal readiness to ensure that funds are allocated in a way that builds capacity and its long-term strategy.
- Assess your organization’s financial health, including reserves and long-term sustainability, in order to have a pulse check on organizational flexibility and risk tolerance.
- Review infrastructural needs such as systems, processes, and capabilities to determine readiness to receive and manage the windfall gift.
- Review your organization’s theory of change and strategic priorities to ensure that funding decisions are aligned with existing mission priorities.
- Assess staffing and leadership capacity to determine where existing teams can expand or accelerate initiatives.
- Evaluate your organization’s ability to scale programs and impact effectively without compromising on equity, quality, or effectiveness.
#3 Determine Priority Investment Areas
Instead of immediately creating detailed budgets for the new funds, organizations can benefit from determining its priority investment categories as a governance tool for guiding and determining allocation decisions while preserving flexibility.
- Create priority investment categories such as capacity building, program expansion, and financial resilience in order to develop a structured governance framework that guides how your leadership and board review and allocate windfall funds.
- Leverage these categories as a governance tool in order to support decision-making and as a guide for how your leadership and board evaluate and balance trade-offs between immediate needs and long-term investments to strengthen your organizational capacity.
- Align your investment priorities within each category of your organization’s mission and strategic goals in order to ensure that your decisions are focused on long-term impact.
- Create metrics to evaluate each investment category in order to facilitate transparent, consistent, and accountable governance in your decision-making.
#4 Engage Board and Stakeholders in Decision-Making
Windfall gifts can transform an organization’s direction, and it’s important to have good governance. In order for governance to be effective, it’s vital for the leadership, board, and stakeholders to have a shared decision-making process.
- Partner with your board to have structured, strategic discussions to determine long-term priorities and intended outcomes for the windfall.
- Involve staff and leadership teams in order to determine operational needs, internal capacity, and opportunities to enhance programming.
- Engage staff, donors, and community stakeholders where appropriate to ensure that funding decisions that are made reflect the lived experiences and community needs.
- Develop and maintain transparent communication practices in order to keep stakeholders informed on how decisions are made, revisited, and executed over time.
When the Approach is Most Effective
A structured governance approach to windfall gifts is most effective when:
- The organization receives a large, unrestricted gift that is beyond what is expected for annual funding levels.
- There is strong alignment between leadership and the board on the organization’s direction and priorities.
- The leadership is stable and has the bandwidth to engage in multi-year planning that strengthens organizational capacity.
These practices may be more difficult to implement when funding has significant restrictions and does not allow an organization to have discretion on how funds are allocated and spent, when organizations are experiencing financial or operational instability, which requires organizational leadership and the board to prioritize stabilizing it, and when governance structures and decision-making processes are highly fragmented.
Ethical and Community Considerations
The literature demonstrates that windfalls are more than financial events for organizations. They are opportunities to reimagine organizational priorities and impact, strengthen governance, and deepen accountability to the communities they serve.
Key considerations include:
- Maintaining transparency across all stakeholders.
- Including community voices in the decision-making process.
- Avoiding pressure to spend funds too quickly.
- Ensuring investments are aligned with mission and values.
- Using reporting structures to maintain accountability over time.
Conclusion
The literature on windfalls demonstrates the importance of proactive preparation, governance, and strategic planning. Rather than rushing to spend newly acquired funds, organizations should create clear decision-making structures, engage stakeholders, and develop a long-term strategy for how funds are allocated, supported by ongoing reporting and accountability mechanisms.
A windfall is not simply a financial opportunity. Rather, it is a test of an organization’s ability to govern, plan, and invest for long-term sustainable impact.
_________________________________
The Center for Social Impact Strategy (CSIS) is an action-oriented training center and research lab located within the University of Pennsylvania School of Social Policy & Practice. Follow CSIS on LinkedIn to hear about our free, virtual events, including our monthly speaker series, and to get information about our cohort-based executive programs. Our next cohort-based extended learning opportunities include:
- Executive Program in Social Innovation Design (XSD). Starts September 10, 2026. Features 7 months of online curriculum, weekly feedback on assignments, and an on-campus intensive learning experience October 29-30, 2026. Learn More | Enroll. Limited partial scholarships are available.
- Executive Program in Social Impact Strategy (SIS). Starts January 20, 2027. Features 8 months of online curriculum, weekly feedback on assignments, and two formats: Blended, which features an on-campus intensive learning experience March 17-19, 2027; and Online, which is fully online and features an additional class in Design Thinking for Social Impact. Learn More | Enroll in Blended | Enroll in Online. Limited partial scholarships are available.
_________________________________
References
“America’s Top 25 Philanthropists – And Why Musk, Page And Ellison Aren’t On The List” by Matt Durot and Phoebe Liu in Forbes. 2026.
Board Source by Board Source. 2025.
Boards That Make a Difference: A New Design for Leadership in Nonprofit and Public Organizations by John Carver. 2006.
“Deciding How to Invest a Windfall Gift” by The Bridgespan Group, in The Bridgespan Group. n.d.
“Is Your Nonprofit Ready for a Windfall?” by Successful Nonprofits. 2020.
“Nonprofit Good Governance Mechanisms: A Systematic Literature Review” by Ana Licerán-Gutiérrez, Antonio Luis Moreno-Albarracín, Cristina Ortega-Rodríguez, and Lucía Martín-Montes, in Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 34(4), 927–957. 2024.
“Making and Managing Windfall Gifts” by Panorama Global, in Insights. 2022.
“Receiving a Large, Unrestricted Grant: A 90-Day Roadmap” by Panorama Global in Insights. 2023.
“Three Tips for Unlocking Board Effectiveness After a Windfall Gift” by Carmita Semaan, in The Bridgespan Group, 2024.
Yield Giving by MacKenzie Scott. 2025.